Our Story
Wm. Effler Jewelers was established in August of 1920 in Mt. Healthy by William and Clara Effler. It was the first jewelry store in the community.
William Sr. came to Mt. Healthy not only with his previous jewelry store experience, but with a background in jewelry manufacturing and watchmaking that started from age 14. The small store in a frame building at 14 North Main Street was a mom and pop operation with both William and Clara serving the people of the town. As the children grew and matured, they too assisted the operation.
In 1927, the original store, which had become too small, was replaced with a new and larger store on the same site. In 1937, a branch store was opened in College Hill. William Effler Sr. continued with the operation of both until he retired in 1948. At this point, the business was operated as a partnership by William Jr., his sister Rita, and her husband. In 1963 the partnership was dissolved, and William and his wife Dorothy assumed sole ownership of the Mt. Healthy store. They continued this operation until 1982.
In 1982, the business was sold to son-in-law Mark Andrus and daughter Mary Effler Andrus. In July 1989, Mark and Mary opened a second location on Hyde Park Square. That store since relocated to its present location in The Hyde Park Center.
As of March 1st, 2001, the Mt. Healthy location was sold and Wm. Effler Jewelers now operates solely out of our new Madison Road location in The Hyde Park Center.
In September 2007, the business was passed on to the fourth generation. Mark and Mary's son Adam and his wife Marianne look to carry on the tradition of excellent customer service and fine quality products for years to come in the family business.
Along with its mission of serving the client with the "Golden Rule", strides have been made through the years to educate the staff and to make advancements in our repair and manufacturing capabilities. We're very proud to have a staff including 2 certified gemologists appraisers, and 2 very talented craftspeople in our manufacturing shop.
Service Offerings
-
We offer professional jewelry repair services to help restore the pieces you love. Bring your jewelry into our store for an evaluation, and we’ll discuss the recommended repair options with you.
Stop by our store or contact us for more information. Let us help you enjoy your favorite jewelry again!
Repair options and pricing depend on the item’s condition, materials, and the work required.
-
Whether your watch simply needs a fresh battery or requires a more extensive mechanical repair, our experienced team is here to help.
Basic watch batteries installed while you wait
Complete watch evaluations and repairs
Mechanical and automatic watch service
Care for Rolex, Omega, Cartier, and many other brands
Extensive repairs performed by our Master Certified WatchmakerYour watch deserves knowledgeable, professional care. Visit our store for an evaluation and let us help keep your favorite timepiece running beautifully.
Services, turnaround times, and pricing vary according to the watch and repair required. Brand names are used only to identify the types of watches we service; we are not implying authorization or affiliation.
-
Whether you need an appraisal for insurance, estate planning accurate documentation matters.
Our Certified Gemologist Appraiser completes annual certification requirements to maintain current knowledge of industry standards, gemstone identification, jewelry evaluation, and watch appraisal.
We provide professional appraisals for:
Fine jewelry
Diamonds and colored gemstones
Luxury and collectible watches
Estate and heirloom pieces
Insurance documentationTrust your treasured pieces to a qualified professional committed to continuing education and careful evaluation.
Contact us to schedule your appraisal appointment today.
Appraisals reflect market conditions and available information at the time of evaluation.
